Fenway Hotel Autograph Collection

Very Poor
Traveller Type: young couple
  : Didn’t eat there. Room was clean. Walkable to downtown.
  : Our room was right next to the wedding suite. Two weddings back to back. One night we were kept awake until 2am. Had to call front desk to speak to the guests. The next wedding we were woken up at 6:30am by bride and co getting hair/makeup done.

Fair
Traveller Type: young couple
  : The location was beautiful. We were there for baseball so the walk was easy. The property faces the gulf, unobstructed, so…wow.
  : I was so excited about staying at this property, initially. So disappointed in the room, amenities and general ambience. The shower had black stains on the grout (mold?), no handle, a hook and one 20” towel bar, thin and small bath towels, one 1.5” circle of soap, 1 ply toilet paper and tissues, a roll holder located awkwardly behind the seat (fine if you’re a contortionist), an embarrassingly prominent display of grossly overpriced snacks and beverages but worst of all a screeching bathroom door. I was also sadly disappointed that there was a single chair and the view was of the parking lot. All in all, a very disappointing experience. The HiFi Bar was not the classy jazz bar I was led to believe but a “if you can find an empty table and move your own seats to it”, go ahead. Meanwhile, the table with four glasses of water on it was “reserved”. We were there for 75 minutes… no one showed up.

Wonderful
Traveller Type: young couple

Very Good
Traveller Type: young couple

Good
Traveller Type: young couple

Wonderful
Traveller Type: young couple
  : The breakfast was outstanding as was the location... the staff was over the top excellent especially the front desk manager she was superlative!

Wonderful
Traveller Type: young couple
  : Great location and comfortable rooms.

Very Good
Traveller Type: young couple

Wonderful
Traveller Type: young couple
  : Fantastic location (private enough yet walking distance to the charming Downtown Dunedin, also biking trail). Very comfortable bed. Very clean room (I mention somewhere else that the furniture was outdated, but still clean and smells nice). Good staff. Nice vintage feel that feels unique and authentic (some corners have museum design - like a mini museum showroom). Rooftop with great views (sea view). Very reasonable prices (one of the very few times when I was at a hotel and did NOT feel the hotel was trying to rip me off with extra costs - sadly the surprising parking fees stained this first good impression a little bit but almost everything else looked very reasonable).
  : Furniture outdated. Facilities can be basic (example: pool and courtyard). The hotel wasn't upfront in the beginning about the parking fees (which were reasonable but we didn't like not being honest about that additional from the beginning). Nothing too bad to ruin the overall experience (which was still very positive).

Good
Traveller Type: young couple
  : The building looks nice
  : The rooms and bathroom are rather small